Nigeria’s long-standing practice of subsidizing foreign exchange has come under intense scrutiny, with the World Bank’s latest report shedding light on its staggering financial implications. The international lender has revealed that the country’s dual exchange rate system resulted in a staggering N13.2 trillion loss between 2021 and 2023.
The dual exchange rate system, characterized by an official rate and a parallel market rate, created a significant disparity that eroded government revenue. This policy, intended to stabilize the naira and support specific sectors of the economy, inadvertently inflicted substantial financial harm.
Toll on the Treasury
The World Bank’s report delves into the specific costs associated with this policy:
2021: N2 trillion
2022: N6.2 trillion
2023: N5 trillion
These losses were primarily driven by the significant difference between the official and parallel market exchange rates. As government revenue, such as oil and customs duties, was converted at the official rate, the treasury suffered substantial losses.
The Impact on Revenue Streams
The report delves into the specific areas affected by the dual exchange rate regime, including:
Oil and Gas Revenue: Significant revenue losses were incurred due to the disparity between the official and parallel market rates.
Import and Export Duties: The fluctuation in exchange rates impacted customs revenue collection.
VAT: The imposition of VAT on imported goods, particularly those priced in foreign currency, further exacerbated revenue losses.
Company Tax: The dual exchange rate regime affected the tax liabilities of businesses, especially those with significant foreign currency transactions.
Government-Owned Companies: State-owned enterprises, such as NNPC, FAAN, NPA, and NIMASA, experienced reduced revenue due to the exchange rate differential.
The End of Subsidy Era
In a significant policy shift, Finance Minister Wale Edun announced the termination of both fuel and foreign exchange subsidies. This decision, aligned with the World Bank’s recommendations, marks a crucial step towards fiscal sustainability. Edun emphasized the detrimental impact of these subsidies on the economy, necessitating their elimination.
Read Also: Air Peace Faces Slot Allocation Hurdles at London Heathrow
Manufacturers Remain Pessimistic Amid Insecurity, High Costs
A Missed Opportunity
The World Bank’s report highlights the missed opportunities arising from the dual exchange rate regime. The N13.2 trillion lost could have been channeled towards critical sectors such as healthcare, education, and infrastructure, benefiting the entire nation. However, the policy, while intended to support specific segments of the economy, ultimately resulted in a significant drain on public resources.
The World Bank strongly advocates for a unified exchange rate as a crucial step towards economic stability and growth. By eliminating the distortions caused by the dual exchange rate regime, Nigeria can unlock its full economic potential.
Alex Sienart, the World Bank’s lead economist for Nigeria, emphasized the positive impact of the recent policy changes, particularly the removal of the foreign exchange subsidy. He noted that the government’s fiscal position has improved significantly in the first half of 2024, primarily driven by increased revenue.
As Nigeria embarks on a new economic chapter, the lessons learned from the past can inform future policy decisions. By embracing sound economic principles and prioritizing fiscal discipline, the country can achieve sustainable growth and prosperity for all.
